Jackie Leven Gothic Road (Cooking Vinyl)

I knew he was being an idiot, but I also recognized what he resisted about Doll by Doll. Though the noisiest passages of Remember are a match for any Krautrock guitar meltdown, and Bill Price’s abrasive production fit the cultural moment—he’d already worked with the Sex Pistols and the Clash—Doll by Doll were otherwise completely out of step with punk and new wave. God knows they were usually dark and moody enough in their lyric—violence, death, humiliation, heartbreak, the works—but Leven, an avid poetry reader since his teens, had no use for what he calls the “cartoon violence” of punk. “Especially on that first album, we were interested in exploring much heavier emotions than just a fixed adolescent sneer,” he told me in an interview last month.

Best of Chicago voting is live now. Vote for your favorites »

Long story short, the revelation inspired me to follow up on what Leven, now 59, had been up to since Doll by Doll fell apart in 1983. Upon answering that question, I’ve concluded that, note for note and album for album, he just might be the most underappreciated songwriter alive today.

This is how the notoriously autocratic Thomas explains his creative relationship with Leven in an interview on Leven’s 2004 concert video, The Meeting of Remarkable Men: “I envy his voice. He’s a great singer, he’s a great storyteller, and he’s a man’s man, and therefore he’s a lot of fun to work with, because you get that male poetic bonding right away, and that’s a lot of fun artistically. . . . He’s got a deep connection with the land, with geography, with landscape, and we connected immediately on that level. And working with Jackie is . . . When you’re working with people who are your equals, then you’re willing to be submissive to their way. It’s like dogs. Dogs immediately recognize where they are in a hierarchy. They don’t object to being in a hierarchy. . . . If I walk into a room I know pretty much immediately where I fit into the hierarchy of other arty types. I know whether I’m an alpha male in that room or whether I’m somewhere else down the line.”