“At first I was excited. It’s one of my favorite foods,” said Old Town Pour House bartender Karl Fernandez of his challenge, Parmigiano Reggiano. “Then I realized how difficult it would be to use.” Taking a page from challenger Brendan Smith, who based his own drink on honey-mustard gelato, Fernandez made an ice cream with the cheese. “It has an extremely strong flavor,” he admitted. “But if you like PR, you’re going to love this cocktail!”

Best of Chicago voting is live now. Vote for your favorites »

Karl Fernandez makes the Cheese Course

Challenged with Parmigiano Reggiano, Karl Fernandez makes a cocktail for cheese lovers only

The Cheese Course

3-4 oz Parmigiano Reggiano ice cream 3/4 oz Grey Goose la Poire 3/4 oz Stolichnaya honey vodka (aka Stoli Sticki) Drizzle of Fini balsamic vinegar Slice of prosciutto-wrapped grilled pear